| Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | ||||||||
| 1 | Reynolds | Cam Newton QB | 1 | New Orleans | D'Qwell Jackson ILB | 1 | New Orleans | Placico Burress WR | ||
| 2 | Buffalo | Andy Dalton QB | 2 | Arizona | Greg Little WR | 2 | Arizona | Nick Fairley DT | ||
| 3 | Arizona | Von Miller OLB | 3 | Coralville | Phil Taylor DT | 3 | Ankeny | Wesley Woodyard ILB | ||
| 4 | Coralville | A.J. Green WR | 4 | Coralville | TJ Lang G | 4 | Reynolds | Orlando Franklin T | ||
| 5 | Kansas City | Tyron Smith T | 5 | Kansas City | Ryan Kerrigan OLB | 5 | Kansas City | Pernell McPhee DL | ||
| 6 | Miami | J.J. Watt DL | 6 | Miami | Adrian Clayborn, DE | 6 | Los Angeles | Stevan Ridley RB | ||
| 7 | Port Fenton | Victor Cruz WR | 7 | Port Fenton | Roy Helu, RB | 7 | Port Fenton | Mark Ingram RB | ||
| 8 | Chicago | DeMarco Murray RB | 8 | Reynolds | Perry Riley ILB | 8 | Chicago | Kyle Rudolph TE | ||
| 9 | Mt Carmel | Aldon Smith DE LB | 9 | Mt Carmel | Richard Sherman CB | 9 | Mt Carmel | T.J. Yates QB | ||
| 10 | So. California | Marcel Dareus DL | 10 | So. California | Blaine Gabbert QB | 10 | So. California | Anthony Costanzo T | ||
| 11 | Erie | Julio Jones WR | 11 | Erie | Elvis Dumervil, DE | 11 | Erie | Corey Liuget DE | ||
| 12 | Los Angeles | Mike Pouncey C | 12 | Reynolds | Justin Houston OLB | 12 | Los Angeles | Jimmy Smith CB | ||
| 13 | LaCrosse | Patrick Peterson CB | 13 | LaCrosse | Titus Young WR | 13 | Reynolds | Preston Parker WR/Ret | ||
| 14 | Gotham City | Evan Mathis G | 14 | High Sierra | Stefan Wisniewski C | 14 | So. California | Cary Williams CB | ||
| 15 | Michigan | Jake Locker QB | 15 | Michigan | Michael Bennett DE | 15 | Buffalo | Gabe Carimi OT | ||
| 16 | Portland | Jurrell Casey DT | 16 | Portland | Brooks Reed OLB | 16 | Portland | Daniel Thomas RB | ||
| 17 | Ankeny | Antwan Barnes DE-LB | 17 | Reynolds | Akeem Ayers OLB | 17 | Los Angeles | Jed Collins RB-KR | ||
| 18 | Wichita | Torrey Smith WR | 18 | Wichita | Sam Acho, OLB | 18 | Wichita | Marcus Gilbert OT | ||
| 19 | Idaho | Jabaal Sheard DE | 19 | Idaho | Muhammad Wilkerson DE | 19 | Idaho | Colin McCarthy ILB | ||
| 20 | Tri City | Doug Baldwin WR | 20 | Tri City | Randall Cobb, Wr | 20 | Tri City | Jared Gaither, OT | ||
| 21 | Ankeny | Brandon Browner CB | 21 | Miami | Christian Ponder QB | 21 | Arizona | Frostee Rucker DE | ||
| 22 | Ankeny | Nate Solder T | 22 | Iowa | Cameron Jordan DE | 22 | Iowa | Jonathan Baldwin WR | ||
| 23 | High Sierra | Denarius Moore WR | 23 | High Sierra | KJ Wright LB | 23 | Buffalo | Kelvin Sheppard LB | ||
| 24 | Nuevo | Ben Tate RB | 24 | Nuevo | Robert Quinn DE | 24 | new Orleans | Brian DeLa Puente OG | ||
| Round 4 | Round 5 | Round 6 | ||||||||
| 1 | New Orleans | Leroy Hill OLB | 1 | New Orleans | Chris Harris CB | 1 | New Orleans | Bruce Miller RB | ||
| 2 | Arizona | Kendall Hunter RB | 2 | Arizona | Phil Costa C | 2 | Arizona | Chris Hairston T | ||
| 3 | Ankeny | Jake Ballard TE | 3 | Ankeny | Adam Snyder OL | 3 | Ankeny | Rahim Moore S | ||
| 4 | Coralville | Lance Kendricks TE | 4 | Coralville | Colin Kaepernick QB | 4 | Coralville | Jacquizz Rogers RB | ||
| 5 | Kansas City | A.J Jefferson CB | 5 | Kansas City | Jason Hatcher DE | 5 | Kansas City | Justin King CB | ||
| 6 | Miami | Prince Amukumura, CB | 6 | Buffalo | D'quan Bowers DL | 6 | Miami | Cam Heyward DE | ||
| 7 | Port Fenton | Donald Butler, ILB | 7 | Port Fenton | Erik Pears OT | 7 | Port Fenton | Rodney Hudson C/G | ||
| 8 | Chicago | Keenan Lewis, CB | 8 | Chicago | Jeff Otah OT | 8 | Chicago | Matt Giordano S | ||
| 9 | Mt Carmel | Chris Conte, S | 9 | Mt Carmel | Erin Henderson LB | 9 | Mt Carmel | Richard Goodman WR | ||
| 10 | So. California | Lavelle Hawkins, WR | 10 | So. California | Marcus Gilchrist CB | 10 | So. California | Greg Salas WR | ||
| 11 | Erie | Paul Kruger, DE-LB | 11 | Erie | Matt Bosher P | 11 | Erie | Dan Orlovsky QB | ||
| 12 | Los Angeles | Jeremy Kerley, WR | 12 | Los Angeles | Evan Royster RB | 12 | Los Angeles | Terrell McClain DT | ||
| 13 | LaCrosse | Karl Klug, DT | 13 | LaCrosse | Kellen Davis TE | 13 | LaCrosse | Rob Housler TE | ||
| 14 | Erie | Vincent Brown, WR | 14 | Gotham City | Brian Rolle OLB | 14 | Gotham City | Jackie Battle RB | ||
| 15 | Michigan | Craig Steltz S | 15 | Michigan | Will Svitek T | 15 | Los Angeles | Jaiquawn Jarrett S | ||
| 16 | Portland | Scott Chandler TE | 16 | Portland | Mason Foster LB | 16 | Portland | James Carpenter G | ||
| 17 | Tri City | Aaron Williams CB | 17 | Reynolds | Brice McCain CB | 17 | Buffalo | John Moffitt G | ||
| 18 | Wichita | Kyle Love DT | 18 | Wichita | Brian Price DT | 18 | Wichita | Jacquian Williams LB | ||
| 19 | Idaho | Leonard Hankerson WR | 19 | Idaho | Will Rackley G | 19 | Idaho | Delone Carter RB | ||
| 20 | Tri City | Dan Bailey K | 20 | New Orleans | Bryan Scott S | 20 | Tri City | David Carter DT | ||
| 21 | Buffalo | Montrae Holland G | 21 | Buffalo | Quinton Carter S | 21 | Buffalo | Jah Reid T | ||
| 22 | Iowa | Danny Watkins G | 22 | Iowa | Shane Vereen RB | 22 | Iowa | Jonathan Fanene DL | ||
| 23 | High Sierra | Dennis Pitta TE | 23 | Gotham City | Kraig Lumpkin RB | 23 | High Sierra | Charles Clay HB | ||
| 24 | Nuevo | Jason Kelce C | 24 | New Orleans | Kraig Urbik G | 24 | Nuevo | Bruce Carter ILB | ||
| Round 7 | Round 8 | Round 9 | ||||||||
| 1 | New Orleans | Marcus Sherels CB | 1 | New Orleans | Chad Ochocinco WR | 1 | New Orleans | Nick Miller KR | ||
| 2 | Arizona | Vaughn Martin DE | 2 | Arizona | Joe Reitz G | 2 | Arizona | Andre Neblett DT | ||
| 3 | Ankeny | Devin Aromashoda WR | 3 | Ankeny | Dwan Edwards DL | 3 | Ankeny | Logan Paulsen TE | ||
| 4 | Coralville | Dejon Gomes S | 4 | Coralville | David Johnson TE | 4 | Coralville | Dannell Ellerbe LB | ||
| 5 | Kansas City | Jarrett Dillard WR | 5 | Kansas City | Garrett Reynolds G | 5 | Kansas City | Tim Jamison DE | ||
| 6 | Miami | Donovan McNabb QB | 6 | Miami | Sergio Kindle LB | 6 | Miami | Casey Matthews LB | ||
| 7 | Port Fenton | Junior Gallette DE | 7 | Port Fenton | Elbert mack CB | 7 | Port Fenton | Allen Bailey, DE | ||
| 8 | Chicago | Alex Henery K | 8 | Chicago | Khalif Barnes OT | 8 | Chicago | Cody Grimm S | ||
| 9 | Mt Carmel | Austin Pettis WR | 9 | Mt Carmel | John Beck QB | 9 | Mt Carmel | Kahlil Bell RB | ||
| 10 | So. California | Jonathan Casillas OLB | 10 | So. California | Kory Lichensteiger OG | 10 | So. California | Ryan Mallett QB | ||
| 11 | Erie | Sean Lissimore DL | 11 | Erie | Lance Louis G-T | 11 | Erie | Jake McQuaide OLB-LS | ||
| 12 | Los Angeles | Kealoha Pilares WR | 12 | Los Angeles | Jerrel Jernigan WR | 12 | Los Angeles | Akeem Dent ILB | ||
| 13 | LaCrosse | Jayme Mitchell DE | 13 | LaCrosse | Graham Harrell QB | 13 | LaCrosse | Jarrett Bush DB | ||
| 14 | Gotham City | Sione Fua DT | 14 | Gotham City | Armanti Edwards WR | 14 | Gotham City | Joe Lefegrad S | ||
| 15 | Michigan | Daniel Fells TE | 15 | Michigan | Jerious Norwood RB/KR | 15 | Michigan | Ernie Sims OLB | ||
| 16 | Portland | Mike Kafka QB | 16 | Portland | Manase Tonga RB | 16 | Portland | Steve Schilling G | ||
| 17 | Coralville | Kevin Thomas CB | 17 | Reynolds | Lemuel Jeanpierre C-G | 17 | Reynolds | John Phillips FB | ||
| 18 | Wichita | David Caldwell S | 18 | Wichita | Ricky Stanzi QB | 18 | Wichita | Sterling Moore DB | ||
| 19 | Idaho | Christian Ballard DL | 19 | Idaho | Byron Bell T | 19 | Idaho | Tyrod Taylor QB | ||
| 20 | Tri City | Chris Culliver CB | 20 | Tri City | Chris Ogbannaya RB | 20 | Tri City | DJ Smith ILB | ||
| 21 | Buffalo | Marshall Newhouse T | 21 | Buffalo | Ras-I Dowling CB | 21 | Buffalo | Daniel Kilgore G | ||
| 22 | Iowa | Clyde Gates WR | 22 | Iowa | Matt Toeaina DT | 22 | Iowa | Brandon Harris CB | ||
| 23 | High Sierra | Jamarca Sanford S | 23 | High Sierra | Jordan Senn LB | 23 | High Sierra | Kendrick Elllis DT | ||
| 24 | Nuevo | Jason Pinkston G | 24 | Nuevo | Stephen Paea DT | 24 | Nuevo | Chris Pressley FB | ||
| Round 10 | Round 11 | Round 12 | ||||||||
| 1 | New Orleans | Kyle Williams WR | 1 | New Orleans | Dominique Franks CB | 1 | New Orleans | Matt Willis WR | ||
| 2 | Arizona | Anthony Sherman FB | 2 | Arizona | Rashad Johnson S | 2 | Arizona | Josh Gordy CB | ||
| 3 | Ankeny | Corey Graham CB | 3 | Ankeny | Javon Ringer RB | 3 | Ankeny | Dwayne Harris PR | ||
| 4 | Coralville | Sammy Stroughter WR | 4 | Coralville | Brandon Myers TE | 4 | Coralville | Dane Fletcher LB | ||
| 5 | Kansas City | Spencer Larsen RB | 5 | Kansas City | Arthur Jones DL | 5 | Kansas City | Nolan Carroll CB | ||
| 6 | Miami | Jordan Cameron TE | 6 | Miami | Taiwan Jones RB | 6 | Miami | Curtis Brown CB | ||
| 7 | Port Fenton | Terrelle Pryor QB | 7 | Port Fenton | Niles Paul, Wr | 7 | Port Fenton | Jeremy Cain, LS | ||
| 8 | Chicago | Chase Blackburn ILB | 8 | Chicago | Andrew Hawkins WR | 8 | Mt Carmel | Anthony McCoy TE | ||
| 9 | Mt Carmel | Leger Douzable DL | 9 | Mt Carmel | Tyler Palko QB | 9 | So. California | Dontay Moch OLB | ||
| 10 | So. California | Danny Aiken LS | 10 | So. California | Chad Hall PR | 10 | Los Angeles | Thomas Keiser DE | ||
| 11 | Los Angeles | Dion Lewis RB | 11 | Los Angeles | Clint Boling G | 11 | Gotham City | Mistral Raymond S | ||
| 12 | LaCrosse | Evan Dietrich-Smith C | 12 | Gotham City | Lorenzo Booker RB | 12 | Michigan | Lito Sheppard CB | ||
| 13 | Gotham City | Quinn Porter RB | 13 | Michigan | Donte Stallworth WR | 13 | Portland | Donnie Avery WR | ||
| 14 | Michigan | Thomas Davis OLB | 14 | Portland | Greg Jones LB | 14 | Reynolds | Braylon Edwrads WR | ||
| 15 | Portland | Tyler Sash S | 15 | Reynolds | Sergio Brown S | 15 | Idaho | Cecil Shorts WR | ||
| 16 | Reynolds | Dane Sanzenbacher WR | 16 | Idaho | Mike Nugent K | 16 | Tri City | Kellen Clemens QB | ||
| 17 | Wichita | Davon House CB | 17 | Tri City | John Casey HB | 17 | Buffalo | DuJuan Harris RB | ||
| 18 | Idaho | Eric Hagg S | 18 | Buffalo | Chris Rucker CB | 18 | Iowa | Jordan Norwwod WR | ||
| 19 | Tri City | Luke Stocker TE | 19 | Iowa | Derek Sherrod T | 19 | High Sierra | Matt Leinart QB | ||
| 20 | Buffalo | Cortez Allen CB | 20 | High Sierra | Joseph Barksdale G-T | 20 | Nuevo | Chase Daniel QB | ||
| 21 | Iowa | Darrel Young FB | 21 | Nuevo | DeMarcus Van Dyke CB | |||||
| 22 | High Sierra | Martez Wilson OLB | ||||||||
| 23 | Nuevo | Drake Nevis DT | ||||||||
| Round 13 | Round 14 | Round 15 | ||||||||
| 1 | New Orleans | Rob Francois ILB | 1 | New Orleans | Brady Poppinga OLB | 1 | New Orleans | Weslye Sanders TE | ||
| 2 | Arizona | Montario Hardesty RB | 2 | Arizona | Paul McQuistan G-T | 2 | Arizona | Antonio Johnson DT | ||
| 3 | Ankeny | Seneca Wallace QB | 3 | Ankeny | Jarius Wynn DE | 3 | Ankeny | Breno Giacomini T | ||
| 4 | Coralville | Jordan Shipley WR | 4 | Kansas City | Maurice Hurt G | 4 | Kansas City | Charlie Whitehurst QB | ||
| 5 | Kansas City | Michael Palmer TE | 5 | Miami | Alan Ball CB | 5 | Miami | Alex Boone T | ||
| 6 | Miami | Jamaal Westerman OLB | 6 | Port Fenton | Guy Whimper T | 6 | Port Fenton | Wallace Gilberry DL | ||
| 7 | Port Fenton | Justin Rodgers CB | 7 | Mt Carmel | Morgan Cox C | 7 | Mt Carmel | Kevin Ogletree WR | ||
| 8 | Mt Carmel | Steven Hauschka K | 8 | So. California | Patrick Turner WR | 8 | Gotham City | DeMarco Sampson WR | ||
| 9 | So. California | Da'Norris Searcy S | 9 | Los Angeles | Garrison Sanborn LS | 9 | Idaho | Shaun Hill QB | ||
| 10 | Los Angeles | David Carr QB | 10 | Gotham City | D.J. Williams TE | 10 | Nuevo | Virgil Green TE | ||
| 11 | Gotham City | Spencer Johnson DL | 11 | Michigan | Armad Hall RB | |||||
| 12 | Michigan | James Ihedigbo S | 12 | Reynolds | Jake Delhomme QB | |||||
| 13 | Reynolds | Alex Smith TE | 13 | Idaho | DJ Ware RB | |||||
| 14 | Idaho | Carnell Williams RB | 14 | Iowa | Chris Redman QB | |||||
| 15 | Iowa | Tandon Doss WR | 15 | Nuevo | Neil Rakers K | |||||
| 16 | Nuevo | Mark Hzerlich LB | ||||||||
| Round 16 | Round 17 | Round 18 | ||||||||
| 1 | New Orleans | Antwaun Molden DB | 1 | Arizona | Josh McNown QB | 1 | Arizona | Anthony Collins T | ||
| 2 | Arizona | Jonathan Wilhite CB | 2 | Miami | Chastin West WR | 2 | Miami | Steve McClendon DT | ||
| 3 | Ankeny | Mark Brunell QB | 3 | Idaho | Dan Skuta LB | 3 | Wichita | Josh Portis QB | ||
| 4 | Miami | Derrick Mason WR | ||||||||
| 5 | Idaho | Erik Cook G | ||||||||
| Round 19 | Round 20 | |||||||||
| 1 | Miami | Keith Brookings ILB | 1 | Miami | Shaun Suisham K | |||||
| 2 | Idaho | Danny Batten DE | ||||||||